[Post deleted by author]
8 Likes
whoa whoa whoa
lets sloooww down
this guide isnt really good
not much effort
buT nOobie yOu havent evEn reAd it-
i have.
im saying it’s not much effort because the final product ended up being
excuse me but it doesnt even have legs
and the bubbles dont really do anything to help your case
it doesnt even have a
a lid stay
I THINK
lemme just
overall, it’s missing alot of common details that you couldve easily put in the design.
i recommend adding
ahem
pot legs
please :>
5 Likes
I miss when guides actually had effort.. Lets start with the finshed product, it has no legs no pot lid, nothing! Lets add some actual effort to this guide, please?
1 Like
I liked this guide okay. I enjoy how you added a bit of soul to your formatting, I found myself actually enjoying reading it which is really rare for me.
Additionally, I like how the design could really fit into any game, not just a Halloween themed one. It’s perfect for games wanting to add a bit of festivity in their game without making it too Halloween focused.
My only complaint is: I think you could have gone a whole lot FURTHER. I like the sleek, basic designs don’t get me wrong. But similar to how you added bubbles, I would have liked to see you list more optional things to add to the design.
I also think you could maybe add more Halloween themed ideas, like carved pumpkins or custom potions.
I can kind of see why some people are saying you put in little effort, but this definitely isn’t the worst guide I’ve seen. I give this one a solid 5/10, not a bad start but it could have been better
4 Likes
there just isn’t anything to make guides on anymore.
3 Likes
There is a LOT, but they are either really easy to make, or really hard, so nobody does anymore
1 Like
Oookay, lotta notes-- lemme go over these
I can add those as optional, but with the design, they don’t really add much:
I actually tried pot legs many different ways before deciding not to add them, they just didn’t really work with what was already there.
Yep, good option to add in, I’ll definitely put a version in with one. What I have is kinda an open cauldron. I didn’t see much need for a lid in the original design I have in there right now.
We have a full Halloween tag with most of that stuff in there, I didn’t want to dupe any of them. (My worst dread…)
Adding in some things other people said could be put in, so I got that covered >:D
Yeah, I don’t disagree. I just wanted to make a really basic thing that most people could figure out easily, since there aren’t any guides that I’ve seen that have this same thing. I swear my other guides are better than this ;-;
Thanks for all of y’all’s feedback!
4 Likes
Not to be rude but
Can you make the cauldron less…. circle
For me it doesn’t look like a cauldron 
Also took away text-and-barrier-art , cause there’s no text
I see what you’re saying here, but it would be nice to have just one guide where you can find pretty much everything you need (kinda like BSA’s sweets guide).
You could also add your own twist to some items if you’re worried about accidentally copying someone (custom Halloween cookies, specific jack o’lantern designs, etc)/
Most guides are missing pictures anyways, so either way it would be a great resource for someone who prefers a more visual option.
Anywho, that’s just my opinion
2 Likes
Small suggestion:
Add a small line of ‘_ _ _ _’ text or ‘ ___ | ___ | ___’ to add more detail. (Remove the spaces)
(Will also allow text-and-barrier-art to be added)
1 Like
Idea: maybe have some brighter or darker circles in the bubbles so it doesn’t end up looking monochromatic or flat.
This topic was automatically closed 3 hours after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.